Angel: After the Fall (Continuing Series)

Creator: Brian Lynch, Joss Whedon
Publisher: IDW Publishing
Genre: Fantasy, Drama, Horror, Comic
Rating: C

The problem with the second half of Angel: After the Fall is that it retains all of the problems of the first half, while losing much of the strengths.  Here, Angel: After the Fall ceases to really retain the tone of the earlier series, but becomes increasingly confusing.  One of the things that I love most about Joss Whedon in general is the humour, even if it’s something that makes you stop and scratch your head for a moment or feel bad because what you’re laughing at shouldn’t be funny.

Here After the Fall embarks on life-post Hell.  Everyone is trying to regroup and reconcile post the trauma that they’ve been through, without having actually lived through due to the tricky nature of time travel, and the world of magic and demons has been fully revealed to the people of L.A.  Throughout this arch the issue of humanity is approached repeatedly, as is the issue of how to make amends and overcome past deeds – which I have to admit relates really well to the overall theme of Angel the series.

The big problem that I had with the first half of After the Fall was that the art isn’t consistent, a problem that pops up once again in this half.  I actually really liked the art at the start of this half, but then that arch finished and things changed and once again I was left questioning who was who and what the hell was going on.  Making things worse is that there is a lot less overall continuity here, and many of the storylines of different arches are pretty much dropped at the end.  There seems to be less continuity among the characters, making the big reveals to be just all that much more confusing.  Another big issue that I had was that characters are introduced or reintroduced, then forgotten about.  I really did like how Nina and Kate returned to the series, but they seemed to be forgotten about midway through – similarly Gwen returns, then disappears.  This happens as well with main characters, and while this is sometimes covered by little miniseries that occur alongside the greater arch of After the Fall, the whole thing gets rather confusing.  Perhaps I was just missing the cues within the individual comics that a miniseries was coming up, but at times it really appeared as though I was reading a series that had crossover episodes with another show that I hadn’t watched yet.

The other problem is that a lot of the humour is really gone. The show worked really well as the opposition of two forces; usually Angel against someone else, and most notably in the final season Angel against Spike. The dynamic of the two souled vampires was one that in my opinion really saved the show (even if it didn’t go so far as to actually save the show), and is one that was really lacking in the comics. A lot of the time either Angel is gone, Spike is gone, or they’re both gone, and we’re left questioning where they are, what’s going on, and why is this so dark and bleak. I can do dark and bleak, but I like Joss because it integrates both the dark and bleak with the light and humourous really nicely. This is lacking here.

Another note; I really did like how this arch made reference to the many people that Angel has lost, both in terms of character deaths and actor deaths. I missed Lorne in the second half of the series, although I really respect the decision to not use him following the death of Andy Hallett I don’t think they did enough to explain his absence. There’s a shot later on in the series that shows all the Angel dead, with Wesley, Cordelia, Fred, and Lorne each being pictured (I can’t remember if Doyle was also shown), although Lorne’s death is never explained or even stated – it isn’t clear in this continuation if Lorne is still alive and just elsewhere – continuing his estrangement from the Angel crew following the demands Angel made of him in the finale – or if he’s died off screen.  Through the use of Wikipedia I was able to discover that there was a special Lorne tribute comic, which I love, but this wasn't explained in this comic, which I dislike.